2021.10.28
Appeal decision report – “THEMICRONEEDLE (MICRONEEDLE is written in Katakana)” was allowed to be registered because it is unreasonable to say that it consists solely of a mark indicating quality in the fields of the designated goods in a common manner
October 29, 2021
Noriko Yashiro
Appeal number | Rejection 2021-003287 (JP Appl. No. 2019-091804) |
---|---|
Case summary | “![]() |
Date of decision | September 28, 2021 |
Demandant (Applicant) | Yokoyama Pharmaceutical Co.,Ltd |
Trademark(s) |
(The katakana portion “ |
Designated Goods/Services and Class(es) |
Sheet cosmetics using microneedle technology; cosmetics using microneedle technology in class 3 |
Judgement |
The applied-for-trademark consists of the character string “ The applied-for-trademark should be considered as a whole in appearance because the letters are the same size at an equal spacing interval. Further, the sound is not lengthy and it could be naturally pronounced at a breath, as a whole. In addition, it is reasonable to say that traders and consumers should perceive the combination of “THE” and “
The appeal examiners did not find that “ With the above in mind, it is unreasonable to say that the applied-for-trademark consists solely of a mark indicating quality in the fields of the designated goods in a common manner. Thus, the refusal decision in the examination stage should be withdrawn. |
Comments |
The applicant successfully argued that the following “THE XX” (when XX seems to be the common name/descriptive name of the designated goods/service) were considered distinctive and registered in earlier cases: i) “THE ALOE” (Reg. No. 5988525) ii) “THE HERBS” (Reg. No. 5885096) Designated goods: Cosmetics containing several herbal extracts selected for optimal combination in class 3, and others iii) “THE SKIN” (Reg. No. 6003357) Designated goods: Cosmetics in class 3, and others iv) “ v) “ vi) “ vii) “theVR” (Reg. No. 6043778) viii) “The house” (Reg. No. 5385665) ix) “the room” (Reg. No. 5447732) x) “THE MLP” (Reg. No. 5787130) |